Sunday 31 January 2016

Extra-Marital and Non-Marital Sexual Love


This was written over a year ago after my parish priest mentioned non-marital sex was not a sin. I studied my Bible and talked to friends who were interested in the topic, but I had not published it because it could be misconstrued; however, I am finally at the place to publish it.  Please read my post on Sex, Celibacy and Hebrew Words to better understand more of my thoughts on Christian sexuality.
My home church is in a liberal parish in a liberal diocese (my opinion) where living together without marriage doesn't prohibit people from becoming ordained clergy including the priesthood. My parish priest brought up positives of living together prior to marriage in his Maundy Thursday homily. He did not give scriptures or Biblical word histories in coming to that conclusion; but I had arrived at that conclusion several months ago after doing a Bible study and discussing the topic with friends interested in this topic from a Biblical and moral standpoint. This is from that study.
Modern dictionaries define words as they are currently used. In using a modern dictionary to define an old or ancient word can lead to error or confusion. Examples in the King James Bible. the word amazement meant terror; bowels meant heart or emotions; and careful meant anxious. Today's meaning is quite different for those words and many others. The Bible seems to be very specific in the use of adultery and fornication. I wanted to delve deeper into the definitions and determine if they are or are not interchangeable.
In the Old Testament, the word "adultery" comes from the Hebrew word "niaph" and my Bible dictionaries gave several meanings: a person who had (a) sex with a married woman; (b) a married woman who had sex with a man other than her husband, (c) idolatrous worship or (d) to apostatize.
The New Testament Greek words "pornea"  is often translated "fornication;" and akatharsia is often translated "uncleanness."  According to B. A. Robinson, " By simply defining the words in a narrow or wide sense, religious liberals and conservatives can totally change the meaning of the Bible."  Whoa!  That's a weighty thought as I want to properly understand the Word of God without making it too wide or too narrow but accurate.
Although the Victorians told us fornication means premarital sex, it does NOT specifically or exclusively mean that. According to several Bible dictionaries, the  Greek word, "pornea" can be translated to mean (a) pornography, (b) fornication, (c) idolatry, (d) whoredom; (e) harlotry and comes from the root word "pernaƍ," that means to "sell off" something. It can also mean having sex with a temple prostitute. (1 Cor. 10.8)
Originally, the term fornication was derived from the Indo-European word gwher.  It means "To heat, warm." Derivatives include brand, brandy, forceps, furnace and fornicate. I was curious how forceps made it into the list; the simple answer is forceps were originally  used to carry hot coals. In Roman times, brothels were called "fornices." In 1303 the word came to mean a person who paid a prostitute for sexual services; the prostitute was not a fornicator but a prostitute.
Now that we know a bit of the word history, let's dig back into the Bible and see what it says about sexual immorality. Leviticus 18 gives a long list of what is considered sexually immoral. Premarital sex is not on the list. That chapter might be worth reading in case you're curious. The word nakedness comes from the word "pudendum."  The medical term pudendum is defined as "elating to, occurring in, or lying in the region of the external genital organ."  
In the Old Testament (Leviticus 20:10), adultery (sex between two people where one or both were married or engaged to another) was treated as a capital crime - a stoning to death offense. Since God often compares faithfulness to Him with faithfulness to a mate; and compares loving God with loving our partner - it's not surprising that adultery is considered a sin with capital punishment. God's law makes strong boundaries to help people see how important faithfulness to Him and to a marital partner is.
Pre-marital sex on the other hand, required the male lover to give the father the "bride price" since he had robbed the father of the value of a virgin and shamed the family; plus, at the father's choice, was required to irrevocably marry the girl. (Exodus 22.16-17) While the man in this situation, could not divorce the woman, the Old Testament law allowed her to divorce him if he did not provide adequate, pleasurable lovemaking, clothing or food. (Exodus 21.7-11) Thus, non-marital sex (neither partner was married) was treated as a civil matter based on devaluing the father's "property", NOT as a criminal offense.
Thus, am I stating that promiscuity is Biblical?  Absolutely not!  To follow Jesus's Great Commandment of Loving God and Loving Others (Matthew 22.36-38); sharing a loving, sexual bond is not a sin.  A Biblical test for a loving relationship follows 1 Corinthians 13:4-8a: "Love is patient. Love is kind. Love isn't jealous. It doesn't sing its own praises. It isn't arrogant. It isn't rude. It doesn't think about itself. It isn't irritable. It doesn't keep track of wrongs. It isn't happy when injustice is done, but it is happy with the truth. Love never stops being patient, never stops believing, never stops hoping, never gives up. Love never comes to an end."  If an unmarried couple can have an intimate relationship that is based on that loving scripture, then I don't see it as anti-Biblical.
In summary, Adultery was treated as a "sin" resulting in death by stoning. The Bible didn't state "Yes, non-marital sex is okay" but the law treated it as a human situation, not as a crime. Rather surprising since the law was given about 3,400 years ago! Comments by other Bible writers about fornication can't change the fact of what God said.
In the Bible, God comes as a fire or is compared to a fire that burns away the chaff. Since the root word for fornication has many derivates meaning fire or burn. And since Paul says it is better to marry than to burn. Could that be interpreted that a couple who has pre-marital or non-marital sex, rather than just satisfying their sexual desire should marry or at least live together so their intimate relationship causes them to burn away some of the chaff in their life and learn to be less egocentric and more giving and compassionate and to be more like Jesus. That would fit with what my priest alluded to on the Maundy Thursday sermon.
I interpret the Bible as explaining non-marital sex is permissible and holy when shared in a loving, committed relationship with the goal of being more Christlike; however, sex to "scratch an itch" without love, commitment or a goal for greater holiness could be emotionally or spiritually damaging to the individuals. Persons who still hold the sex until marriage is the only Biblical way to enjoy the delights of sexual intimacy, would do best to follow Paul's teaching in 1 Timothy 1:19 " Cling to your faith in Christ, and keep your conscience clear. For some people have deliberately violated their consciences; as a result, their faith has been shipwrecked."